Thursday, April 11, 2019
Mormons and Facebook for Dummies
Facebook Censorship could happen because of Facebook manipulations of the things that show up in your news feed because Facebook uses algorithms to define your interests and uses the history of the things you have clicked on in the past to define what to show you in your news feed. This is not really censorship, but it is annoying if people are posting things that you want to see, but that Facebook deems you would not be interested in. The way to change this over time is to seek out those friends you want to see their statuses and updates. However, even more common is the user directed Facebook Censorship that happens when people take steps to block you from seeing posts, unfriend you, delete your posts or comments (made on their wall or in response to their posts or comments). This happens more frequently than you may think. Sometimes there is no way to know that this is going on unless you are able to use a different Facebook account to see the response to your posts.
If you do not want to become a victim of this behavior you should know a few things;
1. Do not post anything related to religion or your religious views in public on Facebook.
2. Do not mention any of the following (even if you are referencing them for educational purposes);
- Cults
- Mind control
- Brainwashing
- Racism
- Polygamy
- Polyandry
- Fallibility of religious leaders
- Cognitive Dissonance
- Former abuses by religious leaders (especially past or present Mormon/LDS leaders)
- "Lying for the Lord"
- Blood atonement
- Adam-God doctrine
- Temple ceremonies
- Masonic rights
- Gay marriage or gay rights
- City Creek Mall (unless you are praising how nice it is)
- Mountain Meadows Massacre
- Kirtland Banking Society
- Misogyny
3. Do not mention any links that provide information about LDS church history besides LDS.org, Mormon.org or JosephSmith.net
By following these simple steps you can be assured that Facebook will continue to do what they do and only show you the stuff you want to see.
Happy Never Ending Scrolling!
Monday, May 9, 2011
My Church Resume
I am the oldest of 5 children and, from as young as I can remember, my family regularly attended the LDS church. I don't really remember many specifics, but I remember that I was all in and believed 100% in pretty much everything I was taught. I remember feeling very special when I was baptized. I also remember feeling very special most of the time as I reflect on my early years growing up in the church. When I "graduated" from Primary, a friend and I went back to sharing time for a couple of weeks to visit after we weren't supposed to be going to primary any more because we loved Primary. There was one especially nice lady in Primary that we all loved and we didn't want to graduate to Sunday School and have to leave.
I also remember being involved as an extra in the play called, "My Turn on Earth". I was very excited to be able to do that. I think primary was different when I was a kid than it is now. We sang songs like "Popcorn popping on the apricot tree" and "Give said the little stream" which have messages of sharing, kindness and enjoying the beauty of nature found all around us. It seems like I was also taught moral concepts like being honest, being kind and doing the right thing and there was very little emphasis on following the prophet or listening to and obeying what church leaders said. Instead it seems the new songs coming out in primary (since I was in there) have to do with obedience, conformity and stating knowledge about things where no real knowledge (as defined traditionally) can really be had. In my personal opinion, it seems more like brainwashing type affirmations are emphasized where they used to not be so much. Which causes me to wonder if children growing up in the church nowadays will be even less likely to question the authenticity of the church's claims than I was or if it will be that much more difficult for them when they do...I don't know.
I was the quorum president in teachers quorum for a short time and really loved my teacher's quorum advisor. When I became a priest, I remember I would get compliments all the time on the way I read the sacrament prayer because I was able to read them well with appropriate emphasis on the words and in a smooth and solemn, yet interesting tone. I believed I was gifted to some extent in the area of public speaking. When I graduated from high school I went right to BYU Provo for the summer term following my graduation (since that was the only time I could get in). I loved BYU. I had a much easier time living on campus than off, however.
After the fall semester I came home to earn money to go on my mission for nearly a year. I got a job framing houses when I came home and am grateful for that experience. My boss was LDS and he was instrumental in helping me prepare for my mission. It was during this time that I was riding on a spiritual high and I had several special spiritual experiences that really strengthened my testimony and resolve to serve a mission. It was during this time that I received what I believed to be a revelation regarding faith and that it is truly the power to create. I also believed that I received a revelation that the current president of the church had passed away and I thought I received some words from him as a spirit confirming that he had indeed passed away and he was comforting me and encouraging me. I have written more about this experience here.
I was called to serve in San Antonio Texas speaking Spanish. In the MTC my companion was the assistant to the branch president and I was the assistant to the assistant...whatever that was supposed to mean. I really enjoyed the MTC and did not have any doubt that I was in the right place doing the right thing at the time. The transition to the mission field was kind of difficult because I went from studying in a classroom most of the day and eating in a cafeteria at a place about the size of a large high school to going out and riding a bike all day around west San Antonio. I was physically exhausted when I came home every night and I truly missed all the social interaction that was available in the MTC. Now, I was living in a small 3rd story apartment stuck with one guy all day long riding a bike all day. This was hard. It didn't help that my companion, while very intelligent and likeable didn't say very much. I honestly think he was not very social and really struggled getting out and talking to people. However, I do think the mission helped him to overcome this to a certain extent.
About a year and a half into my mission I was called to be a zone leader and had a really great time in that capacity. When I returned home from my mission after a couple of years attending the singles ward, I was called to be the Elder's quorum president. I adjusted well to life back home, although it was an adjustment that took some time nonetheless.
It was while I was serving as the Elder's quorum president that a certain lovely young woman caught my eye. I called her up to invite her to a ward family home evening activity and we ended up talking almost the whole night on the phone. Needless to say, we really hit it off and decided to get married shortly thereafter. About six months later we were married in the Portland, OR temple. I also enjoyed going to the temple and was a set apart veil worker prior to getting married.
Once married, I continued to hold various callings while staying active in the church. I was an adviser to the teachers quorum, Sunday School counselor, Primary worker, nursery leader, Elder's quorum second counselor, Sunday School adult gospel doctrine teacher, Sunday school president, Deacon's quorum adviser and cub scout wolf leader. I am currently serving as the cub scout wolf leader in my ward.
I guess the whole reason I wanted to give all that history about myself is to further declare that I believed 100% in the religion that I was brought up in. It was not until I was a gospel doctrine teacher that I ever caught any wind that the church might not be all that it claimed to be. And, even then, I did not give any serious consideration to the difficult questions I was posed. It was not until after I had moved to a different ward and a couple of years had passed before I really began to seriously question my beliefs and consider all the evidence surrounding the history of the church.
I am also not sure what specifically led to my questioning the authority claims of the church or being able to look somewhat objectively at the history of the church (not giving Joseph Smith 100% of the benefit of the doubt), but I know doubts crept up upon learning about Joseph's polygamy and all the problems associated with that. Those doubts were only solidified as I learned more about all the details of the polygamous affairs through books I later read on the subject. It seems to me that it is fair to say that my whole time growing up and serving in the church, I was never exposed to any of the more sordid and potentially faith damaging information that I became aware of after I started actually asking questions about who Joseph Smith really was and wanted to know more about his actual history. That and I had to be willing to read from sources of historical information that were not necessarily church approved or sanctioned. I think this is a hard obstacle for some to overcome, however, I think that there is plenty of difficult stuff that can be found in authorized church sources if one desires to find them and look at things said with half an objective eye to a truth that makes sense.
I hope this serves to let people know that I was not always a doubter and for the vast majority of my life I was 100% in and had no doubt about the authenticity of the claims of the church. I also find it interesting that I could go my whole life being brought up in the church and not even be aware of so many things.
(Please note: When using Firefox web browser, if you type a comment without logging in first, your comment may disappear when attempting to submit. To avoid this, login first and then type comment or always copy comment before attempting to submit.)
Saturday, January 29, 2011
Quick! Change the channel
I have two thoughts about this. 1. When I watch TV sometimes (well, OK, usually) I am not fully present (however, this occurs much less now than it used to). I know that I am not fully present when I do not even realize that commercials have come on. I originally did not want to focus on not being fully present in this post, but my thought about it is that many people spend much of their lives not being fully present. I know when I was at church I was not usually fully present. If someone were to ask me what all was said in a sacrament meeting, I usually would not be able to tell you very much. I might be able to just convey the basic ideas I got out of it, but, by and large, I could not give a full account of what was said. After all, it is the same old stuff, all the time. Sound bite after sound bite of faithful blather is all you ever get at church. Deep thinking and discovery seem, to me, to be discouraged. Since I have awakened to the reality of what the church did to me, I am more present than ever. Words now mean things to me and I can recall with much more clarity everything that is said. I am more present because I am allowed to freely think about things, process them and draw my own conclusions. It sounds terrible, but I really didn't think very much for myself as a believing member of the church. In the church, the thinking has been done for you. Thinking was not required, so, I always had an excuse for not thinking. And, even though I was not fully aware of it, I liberally applied that excuse.
My second thought is about about channel changing. 2. When I change the channel, I am looking for something else. Something else that is more interesting than a commercial. I think there is something similar in our cognitive process, which we experience when we think, to changing the channel. The difference is that when I change the channel on TV to avoid the commercials, this is a passive process and I am only doing so to avoid a little discomfort (the subjecting of myself to advertising messages or poor quality television). When it is done in the mind concerning perceptions of reality, it is to avoid very real discomfort that the mind actually can not handle if the thought is dwelt on for too long. The signs of this are depression and a feeling of helplessness - at least unless and until the contradictory thought can be fully dealt with or dispelled. Sometimes we are under the illusion that we have dispelled all of our cognitive discomfort (or dissonance) but usually, at least in my opinion, if we are seeking to maintain a paradigm of thought at all costs, regardless of the discomfort it causes, we will only experience further symptoms.
Examples of changing the channel when cognitive dissonance is encountered in the church or its teachings include;
- Doing more of the stuff you think you are supposed to be doing to help dispel contradictory thoughts (e.g. home/visiting teaching, reading scriptures or conference addresses, saying prayers, devoting more time to callings, etc.) The thinking goes along the lines of; Satan must be putting these thoughts in my head to lead me astray, so I should do more to make sure I am holding fast to the iron rod so I can't be led astray.
- Personally attacking the person who is asking the question, or causing the uncomfortable thought to present itself. People who create cognitive dissonance in believing members of the church (and there are some of us who enjoy doing so ;), at least when they push the issue, are very frequently labeled as stirring up contention, being of the devil or angry. All of these essentially amount to personal attacks of the individual asking the questions of the believer. It is difficult for me to not be perceived as being angry when I am being personally attacked and put down, though.
- Thinking about something you have experienced in your life that you believe was proof of the principle in question (e.g. thinking about anytime something good happened when you paid your tithing or when you imagined that you felt the spirit really strong, etc.). Which leads to...
- Feeling the need to bear testimony of the topic or question. (Basically pronounce the truth of something without having to actually deal with the ramifications of it or think about it too much) This tactic is extremely popular in LDS circles.
I know there have been times that I have been engaged in a discussion (or a thought pattern) and will find myself jumping around in thought and argument looking for some place more comfortable. I know that when I believed in the church, and I actually was thinking, I did this quite a bit. The real awakening occurred for me when I had no where else to jump to for comfort (or to ease the cognitive dissonance) when thinking about what the church taught and what it must mean.
The problem is, many people do not recognize when they are doing this. If you had attempted to point out my jumping ways when I was a believer, I would have attacked you for accusing me of doing such a thing (usually via an ad hominem - or personal attack) because to point out such a thing would have been perceived to be a personal attack on me. However, anyone who accused me of doing such a thing would have been correct, I was just not ready or willing to hear it. To respond, I would have said things to point out some weakness in the character of the person that I have observed. I might have accused a person of being mentally unstable, or of being possessed by the adversary. I would have probably attacked something they have said that they believe or bring up some past action that was obviously a mistake and dwell on that to discount any point you may be making as having credibility. I might have even made such a personal attack out loud, but I would definitely be thinking it, which is another form of jumping away from the uncomfortable thought. I am much less inclined to engage in such personal attacks now, but it causes me to wonder how to prevent people from seeing such an observation (as mentally changing the channel on an idea) as a personal attack. I don't know if it is possible in many cases.
An example of changing the channel for me was when I encountered the question I asked myself, "Why does the Book of Mormon directly contradict statements found in the Doctrine and Covenants? (Like the teaching on Polygamy: The Book of Mormon says that David and Solomon's polygamy was abominable, but D&C 132 says it was condoned by The Lord) When I first endeavored to answer this question, I would not stay on point with an answer to address the contradiction directly. To do so would have been to say that either the Book of Mormon or Doctrine & Covenants must be wrong (or that God or Joseph Smith changed their mind). Rather, I would change the channel and jump to some excuse or try to find some loophole that could possibly explain the discrepancy.
One response to this particular question is that the Book of Mormon goes on to say that if the Lord decides polygamy is the way to go, he'll then condone it. Even though this point could possibly be considered, it declares that polygamy is definitely an eternal principle with God (and all that this means) and, it begs the question, does the Lord change his mind on polygamy then and what is it that causes him to say it's ok for some but not ok for others? Answers to these questions needed to be answered for me to experience congruence on the question of polygamy (and the apparent contradiction), but neither can be answered with any certainty by church leaders or correlated publications. I had to say "I don't know" the answer to either question. This either meant it was not important (if it was not important then why am I giving so much of my time to the group that is proclaiming such things?) or not necessary for me to know. Neither conclusion satisfied me.
It is rather easy to jump away from a specific question at hand (and not deal with the particular ramifications of it), when you have trained yourself to do it, but, I do not think it is healthy. I think, done too much, this sort of jumping around to find something to latch on to, to preserve our foregone conclusion (or faith), only creates dis-ease or neglect in other areas of our mental lives. However, I am not prepared to say that believers are unhealthy, because I think this is impossible to say for certain in all cases, but I can point to findings that make it easy to conclude that Utahns are more depressed than the rest of the country and commit suicide in larger numbers than anywhere else in the country.
So what is it that causes us to jump away from things, or change the channel of thought in our mind, and why is it so hard for some to recognize that they are engaging in this behavior?
I think what causes us to jump in thought from one thing to another is mental conditioning that we perfect throughout our lives to maintain our belief structure. We become experts at avoiding having to address the question at hand (that contradicts our belief structure in some way) in our thoughts, by jumping to the next topic. This is actually kind of amusing to witness, when one is aware of what is going on. It happens with frequency in LDS sunday school. The teacher or participant may pose a question that could be considered a contradiction to doctrine or difficult thing to answer because it would require speculation in addition to what is actually printed in the correlated manual.
I experienced this first hand one time when, during a lesson on early church history, the teacher asked why Joseph might have experienced so much persecution. Of course, I was thinking that all his persecution was mostly made up when he claimed to experience it early on, but, if he did actually experience any real persecution, maybe it was because he was generally regarded by his community as a charlatan, and was even convicted in a court of law for scamming people. I decided to actually voice my thought in class that perhaps the reason Joseph claimed to experience such persecution is because he was convicted in a court of law for being who people claimed he was. The channel changing that ensued after I made my comment was incredible to behold. One person claimed that everybody that accused Joseph of such activities was falsely accusing him. One person claimed that his good works far outweighed anything bad that people perceived he might have done and another went on to say that it was his treasure seeking that enabled to him to believe that he could be led to the golden plates.
All of these answers were a form of changing the channel to deal with my comment. Nobody wants to dwell too long on the fact that after Joseph Smith claimed to have seen God and Jesus that he engaged in the practice of acting as a seer for people who were seeking buried treasure. This thought is just too painful because it might call into question the kind of person Joseph Smith was and might cause us to ask, did he really see what he claimed to see or was he a confidence man (or con artist)? This question is much too painful, so we need to quickly change the channel and either bear our testimony of the divinity of Joseph's calling as prophet of the restoration or move on in some other way.
I have gone on long enough. Go ahead and change the channel now. May we all find comfort in our thoughts and may they be cognitively congruent. In the name of cheese and rice, Amen.
Monday, August 31, 2009
Sunday School Musings - Leaving Mormonism but not leaving it alone
Since my blog here is pretty obscure and there is not much chance people that know me will be lingering here, I decided to try some therapy by being open about my feelings related to my religion. Religion is such a polarizing topic among people and I find it difficult to talk about in many settings. In fact, it has become a sore point even between my spouse and I. I grew up active in the LDS faith (also known as Mormon, a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints), served an honorable 2 year mission for the church, married my wife in the Portland, OR temple and was very tbm (true believing Mormon) up until about a year or so ago. My story about coming out of the fog as it relates to my religion, so to speak, is a long one and I will save that story for a future blog post (or a book, probably). Suffice it to say that I came to learn for myself that the religion of my youth was not everything that I had been taught that it was. Of course, the deeper into the depths of the history of my religion that I explored, the more I found a larger pattern of deception and dishonesty. Obviously, this has been a stark experience for me and has caused a major upset in my entire world-view, not to mention the affect it has had on my family. However, the upside is that I feel more genuine, authentic and honest about the circumstances I find myself in, and somehow, I feel refreshed and exhilarated - even in the face of severe discouragement and disapproval expressed by most of my close friends and family when they learn of my position.
This post is specifically about my experience in Sunday School yesterday, which I normally do not attend, because I can't stomach the deliberate misinformation that is presented there. I tried for a little while to call attention to the ways in which myths were being presented as truths and bring balance to the one sided presentation of history, but I soon realized a few things; 1. The people there really don't want to hear the other side to what they are being taught and 2. I don't enjoy the confrontations that invariably result from my opposing viewpoint. So I have relegated myself to keeping my mouth shut and suffocating from the stifled story telling or just not attending altogether.
Yesterday, however, I found myself sitting in Sunday School for a couple of reasons, 1. My 2 year old son had fallen alseep on my lap and, rather than try to move him, I decided to just stay put which lands me in Sunday School. The other reason is the member of the bishopric who was doing the presenting for the 3rd hour combined class had asked me to read a long quote for him (since, apparently, I can read out loud pretty well for an adult). Anyway, as I was sitting there I was doing my usual internal moaning and groaning (but I am also always curious to hear how various topics will be spun wildly out of control by those in the class, since this can also be pretty entertaining.) The topic of the class was on the death of Joseph Smith (founder of Mormonism).
The first thing that crosses my mind when this is talked about is how Mormons insist on always calling this event in history the "Martyrdom of Joseph Smith". I guess the Mormons want to consider him a martyr for their cause but, the reality is, his death was a direct result of his illegal and unsustainable actions more than anything else. He didn't die in defense of his cause, he died in spite of the cause he supposedly represented. I don't by any means feel that his murder was justified, but I do not believe that he was totally innocent at death either. I also think that the continued emphasis on Joseph as a martyr lends credibility to his work that really should be presented on balance with the problems with Joseph's behavior in acting as a tyrant.
So, here are my observations: One person posed what I think was the best question, which is still very difficult to sufficiently answer and that is, "If Joseph were a complete fraud, how could he have withstood all the persecution (namely, being tarred and feathered, beaten, nearly castrated and imprisoned) and still maintained the charade?" My answer to this question is that either he truly believed he had some sort of divine mandate, which is possible, or he stuck it out because the benefits (or potential perceived benefits) were greater in his mind than the persecution. After all, if you are running a program where you have potentially unlimited power over a very fast growing and influential societal group and you are able to sleep with pretty much any woman you want at the same time...maybe that was just too good to give up. In spite of the persecution, I'm sure Joseph was always looking for ways to get out of the trouble he was in. He eventually was able to escape Liberty Jail by bribing the guard(s) and he was able to convince the jailer at Carthage that he needed protection from mobs and was able to stay in the jailers loft above the normal jail. After all, we are talking about an extremely charming, charismatic, personable and influential fellow. He was a master of spin and deception and whatever he couldn't spin in his lifetime was eventually spun by his successors later on. Persecution was especially well spun by Brigham Young (and, I'm sure, enhanced) because he knew the galvanizing effect of persecution on the saints' resolve. I'm sure the persecution heaped on Joseph became more exaggerated as time wore on simply to re-enforce and sustain belief in his prophetic call. Frankly, I can sympathize with those that openly opposed Joseph and even those that resorted to violence against him considering the effect his teachings were to have on existing or surrounding communities in that day. So, in essence, my position is we need to be sure that the persecution we are citing is not exaggerated, number 1, and number 2, in order to be able to answer that question of how he could keep up the charade, we need to understand Joseph's true mindset at that time, which I don't think very many really did in his day.
My next observation was a bit refreshing and somewhat comical. There is this older couple that attend our congregation that are extremely intelligent (I'll call them Bro. and Sis. R.). He is a former stake president counselor and our resident authority on all things surrounding Hebrew history. He is not shy about providing further insight and enlightenment on symbolism and the history of the scriptures. He very much toes-the-company-line as far as the church is concerned. His wife, Sis. R., on the other hand, is extremely intelligent as well, but she comes across as not being so sure about things, at least not as sure as her husband. She is well read on the history of the church and seems to have persistent doubts about several things. She often chuckles when she hears things said over the pulpit and openly questions things she wants to make sure don't make it into the subculture of Mormonism. I absolutely loved it when she spoke in sacrament meeting a few months ago on the story of Job. She began by saying she found the story offensive, likely untrue and therefore she was going to omit discussing the story entirely, instead choosing to focus on other points surrounding the topic of adversity. She brought up many questions in her talk that remained unanswered when she was done, and closed by reiterating her resolve to remain faithful despite her unanswered questions. I think she is a closet unbeliever, but can't go over that line and stay married to her husband, who is the epitome of a pillar in the faith. I really look forward to her comments in Sunday school because she often says what I am thinking. So, when the instructor asked for someone in the class to give a brief synopsis of the events leading up to the death of Joseph Smith, Bro. R. pipes up and offers a classic version of the well spun church tale...updated to include recently acknowledged events. He said that "church dissidents" (including William Law, former 2nd Counselor in the church first presidency) published a scandalous newspaper called the Nauvoo Expositor. Then the city council decided to not permit the paper to continue to be published so they voted to authorize the destruction of the press. He then went on to say that Joseph as the mayor of Nauvoo was within his rights to permit the destruction of the press because of the powers granted to him through his city charter. Frankly I ignored the rest of what he said, because I was really trying to take in this justification. This is, to me, so classic. Since a man writes up a city charter that could potentially violate the rights of a member of that city, it's OK. And should that sort of behavior be encouraged then? Just because I can set up a local government that entitles me to take something that belongs to you and destroy it, that makes it OK? This is such a slippery slope. I wanted to say, "So if I'm the mayor of our city and I want to destroy your property - and it says it is OK in the city charter - does that make it OK? This is the question that is ignored. People should really begin by asking themselves would the behavior be OK if I were on the receiving end? Would it have been OK for a spiritual leader to come and seduce my wife and take her with or without my permission? These are uncomfortable questions that no one likes to consider, so maybe if we ignore them, they will just go away. And so it goes...